美术摄影还不错，部分镜头可圈可点，剧本一般在叙事上没花任何心思，有几场戏拍出了黑帮片的气质，但整体上还是松散平庸的。演员方面，夏雨自身条件和演技完全支撑不了主角人设，李立群技高一筹算是最出彩的，金士杰最后一场戏有亮点，谭凯差强人意，年轻演员又拉胯了。

和阳光明媚的射雕相比，令狐冲所处的江湖是个非常凄风苦雨的江湖，所有武林大鳄除了风清扬，没一个好人！左冷禅好歹算奸雄，岳不群真小人！带华山整派跪锦衣卫东厂，若是小说真是丢尽五岳剑派的脸！《沧海一声笑》最得笑傲精髓，最喜欢令狐就是他的豪迈洒脱！歌神神演技！叶童实在太不小师妹了

有了花痴对象，就像有了胶原蛋白。结果真的不重要，重要的是在喜欢一个人的过程中变成了更好的自己。

神是神 但有1、、太自恋啦

Perplexity, surrealism & absurdism in a musty, shabby & filthy atmosphere. Many signs inaugurate early on the sheer queerness of whatever revolves around Barton Fink - his own madman's facial expressions, a pitiful & empty hotel, faint sounds that obsessessively bother only him, dubious characters & personalities in Hollywood. But the viewer can still hang in this mess, and somehow (with a little effort) make some sense of what's happening. It's only towards the last third that the increasing contradictions explode into no(n)-sense. The only - and cheap - way to read the movie would be that most of these irreconciliable scenes are in fact dreams or hallucinations. Disappointing.